Debarking, also known as devocalization, is a surgical procedure intended to reduce a dog’s ability to bark loudly. While some owners consider it a solution to excessive noise, the procedure poses significant risks to the animal’s health and well-being.
Photo: Pexels
Understanding Debarking
Debarking involves altering a dog’s vocal cords to muffle or reduce the volume of its bark. Dr. José Arce, president of the American Veterinary Medical Association, told Newsweek, “Devocalization is performed under general anesthesia to remove portions of a dog’s vocal folds or cords.”
The medical term for this procedure is ventriculocordectomy, and it can be partial or total, depending on the desired outcome.
Photo: Pexels
Surgical Methods
There are two primary surgical approaches for debarking: the oral approach and the laryngotomy. The oral approach involves inserting instruments through the dog’s mouth to access the vocal cords. While less invasive and cheaper, this method often results in incomplete vocal reduction and higher chances of scar tissue formation, which can lead to respiratory issues, reports the Humane Society Veterinary Medical Association.
The laryngotomy approach, on the other hand, involves making an incision directly into the larynx. This method provides better access but is more invasive and expensive. It is typically used as a corrective measure if the oral approach fails to achieve the desired results, according to Texas A&M Veterinary Medicine.
Legal Landscape
The legality of debarking varies across the United States. States like Massachusetts, Maryland, and New Jersey have banned the procedure except in medically necessary cases as determined by a licensed veterinarian, according to the American Veterinary Medical Association. Pennsylvania restricts debarking to cases performed by licensed veterinarians using anesthesia, while California and Rhode Island prohibit making debarking a condition for real estate occupancy.
Photo: Pexels
Health Risks Associated with Debarking
Debarking is not without its dangers. The procedure carries risks common to all surgeries, such as bleeding, infection, and complications from anesthesia. Additionally, debarked dogs may experience chronic coughing, gagging, and even aspiration pneumonia, the AVMA reports.
Scar tissue formation, known as webbing, can narrow the dog’s throat, making breathing difficult and potentially requiring further surgery, Newsweek reports. These health issues not only affect the dog’s quality of life but also increase the likelihood of additional medical interventions.
Limited Effectiveness
Even when debarking is successful, its effects may be temporary.
As Dr. Arce told Newsweek, “There’s a chance that the surgery won’t work and the resumption of a near-normal bark may occur within months.”
The procedure does not address the underlying causes of excessive barking, such as anxiety or boredom, which means the behavior often persists or worsens.
Photo: Pexels
Non-Surgical Alternatives
Experts advocate for non-surgical methods to manage excessive barking. Proper training, increased exercise, and environmental enrichment are effective strategies. Behavioral modification techniques, such as positive reinforcement and desensitization, can address the root causes of barking, according to the Humane Society Veterinary Medical Association.
Additionally, no-bark collars that emit citronella spray or provide static feedback are available as alternatives. However, these devices should be used responsibly and in conjunction with training to ensure humane treatment, Texas A&M Veterinary Medicine reports.
Debarking may seem like a straightforward solution to excessive barking, but the procedure poses significant risks to a dog’s health and well-being. With limited effectiveness and numerous potential complications, debarking fails to address the underlying behavioral issues that cause barking.
Responsible pet ownership, involving training and environmental management, offers more humane and effective solutions. As awareness grows, the focus shifts towards methods that respect the natural behaviors of dogs, ensuring their health and happiness without resorting to invasive surgeries.
Take action for dogs and sign our petition to end debarking in the United States!
